art paintbrush canvas paint
  • Publish Date: Posted 6 months ago

Should Art Be Restored?

The Art Of RestorationThe art of restoration is the subject of heated and long-running controversy.Is it lowering the value of art? After restoration, who can an artwork be truly credited to? What are the potential dangers?Conservators are in charge of restoration, which entails repairing damaged or ageing artworks. They are attempting to preserve our cultural history by modifying the artwork. However, there have been numerous restoration disasters, the most noteworthy of which are listed below, weakening the case that restoration is both beneficial and justified.Fresco FiascoThe 'Ecce Homo' artwork by Cecilia Giminez is one of the most well-known examples of restoration destroying art. Cecilia intended to restore the fresco to its original state and preserve the artist's legacy but instead, she created an entirely new piece that could only be ascribed to herself.The original fresco was so dilapidated and ruined that it required the expertise and precision of a professional conservator, which Giminez sadly lacked. What started out as a noble effort to preserve a historical depiction of Christ turned into an accidental mocking of the famed fresco.Nightmare of the Night WatchRembrandt's 'Night Watch' is another example of contentious conservation. The current name of the picture comes from the nature of the paint employed by the artist, which darkened over time. This painting exemplifies another concern with restoration: the difficulty of recreating the exact medium employed when the painting was created. The materials utilised by artists like Rembrandt are not easily identified or simply not replicable in their original state.In order to comply with the wall space limits of the Town Hall in Amsterdam's display area, restorers cropped The Night Watch significantly, removing both space and figures from the composition. The fundamental problem with restoration is that it is extremely difficult (if not impossible) to undo the effects, therefore these discarded figures are irreplaceable...In Opposition to Davinci's StyleThe restoration of Leonardo da Vinci's alleged last painting, "The Virgin and Child with St. Anne," is a further example of debatable art restoration. During the discussion, the artwork was proudly displayed on the walls of the Louvre. The plan to clean the artwork was scrapped in 1993 due to fears that the solvent would harm the picture's "sfumato," a unique blending technique that is Da Vinci's signature. Around 2010-2012, it was agreed that minor restorations, primarily light cleaning of specific places, would be carried out because it was feared that more severe cleaning would result in irreversible damage. After some time had passed, the decision was made to thoroughly clean the artwork.However, the Louvre was quickly accused of overcleaning the masterpiece, which caused the canvas to appear brighter than the Renaissance artist had intended, altering the overall sense of the work.RegulationsExperts in Spain asked for controls on the restoration of artworks last year after a copy of Bartolomé Esteban Murillo's famed Immaculate Conception painting was deformed and the Virgin Mary's face was rendered unrecognisable, despite two attempts to restore the artwork to its original state.Masterpiece Masterminds Or Creative Criminals?The quandary of 'to repair or not to restore?' will always exist in the ever-expanding art world. However, when standing in front of a stunning Botticelli painting in the Victoria and Albert Museum, we should question ourselves if the danger is worth it. Conservators are frequently underappreciated, without them, we would be living in a world devoid of art history. Many artworks would be unrecognisable or non-existent if it weren't for the efforts of such professionals to keep them from deteriorating.Despite the fact that such masterpieces are no longer in their original state and are no longer solely the product of their creator, they remain the most accurate portrayal of their initial presence in art history. One final prominent example that comes to mind is the Vatican's Sistine Chapel, which has been generally commended for its effective restoration in the twentieth century, despite its controversy.Imagine if Leonardo Da Vinci, Michelangelo, and Botticelli didn't exist. Restoration does not always devalue art; on the contrary, it may help to preserve it for future generations.​

Share this Article
Back to Blogs

The Art Of Restoration

The art of restoration is the subject of heated and long-running controversy.

Is it lowering the value of art? After restoration, who can an artwork be truly credited to? What are the potential dangers?

Conservators are in charge of restoration, which entails repairing damaged or ageing artworks. They are attempting to preserve our cultural history by modifying the artwork. However, there have been numerous restoration disasters, the most noteworthy of which are listed below, weakening the case that restoration is both beneficial and justified.

Fresco Fiasco

The 'Ecce Homo' artwork by Cecilia Giminez is one of the most well-known examples of restoration destroying art. Cecilia intended to restore the fresco to its original state and preserve the artist's legacy but instead, she created an entirely new piece that could only be ascribed to herself.

The original fresco was so dilapidated and ruined that it required the expertise and precision of a professional conservator, which Giminez sadly lacked. What started out as a noble effort to preserve a historical depiction of Christ turned into an accidental mocking of the famed fresco.

Nightmare of the Night Watch

Rembrandt's 'Night Watch' is another example of contentious conservation. The current name of the picture comes from the nature of the paint employed by the artist, which darkened over time. This painting exemplifies another concern with restoration: the difficulty of recreating the exact medium employed when the painting was created. The materials utilised by artists like Rembrandt are not easily identified or simply not replicable in their original state.

In order to comply with the wall space limits of the Town Hall in Amsterdam's display area, restorers cropped The Night Watch significantly, removing both space and figures from the composition. The fundamental problem with restoration is that it is extremely difficult (if not impossible) to undo the effects, therefore these discarded figures are irreplaceable...

In Opposition to Davinci's Style

The restoration of Leonardo da Vinci's alleged last painting, "The Virgin and Child with St. Anne," is a further example of debatable art restoration. During the discussion, the artwork was proudly displayed on the walls of the Louvre. The plan to clean the artwork was scrapped in 1993 due to fears that the solvent would harm the picture's "sfumato," a unique blending technique that is Da Vinci's signature. Around 2010-2012, it was agreed that minor restorations, primarily light cleaning of specific places, would be carried out because it was feared that more severe cleaning would result in irreversible damage. After some time had passed, the decision was made to thoroughly clean the artwork.

However, the Louvre was quickly accused of overcleaning the masterpiece, which caused the canvas to appear brighter than the Renaissance artist had intended, altering the overall sense of the work.

Regulations

Experts in Spain asked for controls on the restoration of artworks last year after a copy of Bartolomé Esteban Murillo's famed Immaculate Conception painting was deformed and the Virgin Mary's face was rendered unrecognisable, despite two attempts to restore the artwork to its original state.

Masterpiece Masterminds Or Creative Criminals?

The quandary of 'to repair or not to restore?' will always exist in the ever-expanding art world. However, when standing in front of a stunning Botticelli painting in the Victoria and Albert Museum, we should question ourselves if the danger is worth it. Conservators are frequently underappreciated, without them, we would be living in a world devoid of art history. Many artworks would be unrecognisable or non-existent if it weren't for the efforts of such professionals to keep them from deteriorating.

Despite the fact that such masterpieces are no longer in their original state and are no longer solely the product of their creator, they remain the most accurate portrayal of their initial presence in art history. One final prominent example that comes to mind is the Vatican's Sistine Chapel, which has been generally commended for its effective restoration in the twentieth century, despite its controversy.

Imagine if Leonardo Da Vinci, Michelangelo, and Botticelli didn't exist. Restoration does not always devalue art; on the contrary, it may help to preserve it for future generations.​

Latest Blogs

View All Blogs
Cube Digital Art Nft
NFT Art Explained: Part One

​In 2022, NFTs, bitcoin, cryptocurrency and blockchain seem to be words present in every conversation on technology, art or futurism. Galleries and Auction houses are setting up their very own NF...

Remote Team Working Work From Home
What is an Employer of Record?

​The best prospects aren't always in the best places. Attracting the right talent can be as simple as offering the correct packages to encourage the “work from anywhere” culture. Many global ...

colourful stairs outside travel destination
Benefits Of Hiring A Global Workforce

The number of employees working remotely has increased dramatically in the last year. Although there were some snags at first, many businesses have adjusted to this new normal, and remote working a...

business man reflection blue glass city building
Thinking Of Hiring A Specialist Recruitment Agency? Here Are Some Key Factors To Help You Decide.

Are you having trouble attracting top personnel for your company in a competitive market, or are you still looking for the appropriate match for your team?Because people are a company's most valuab...

latte art heart blue cup and saucer
Check In On Your Employee’s Wellbeing And Improve Their Productivity

​2020 and 2021 have been a whirlwind for all, we have said goodbye to life as we know it and have had to adapt to the realisation that we are in a global pandemic and things may never be the same a...

speech bubble cards
Moving Overseas? Here Are Some Tips For Learning The Language

Moving to a different country is an exciting experience that also provides an excellent opportunity to learn new life skills, such as learning a new language. This may appear to be a difficult unde...

green front door yellow front door
Dual Citizenship - Two Passports Are Better Than One

What is Dual CitizenshipIf you have dual citizenship, you are a citizen of two different countries at the same time. Citizenship of a second country is normally obtained by parentage, birthplace, o...

rubber ducks at sea
Overboard! When Shipping Containers Are Lost At Sea

​According to estimates, over 10,000 shipping containers are lost at sea each year; however, accurate figures are difficult to come by because not all losses are reported.With the rise in consumer ...

green forest land blue sea
Is The Shipping Industry Going Green?

There's no denying how important the shipping business is to modern civilization; if someone needs anything delivered somewhere, shipping will undoubtedly play a role. The carbon footprint connecte...

green houseplants in pots
Should You Consider A Specialist Moving Company?

​So you've made the decision to relocate... One of life's major pressures is the logistics of itemising, packing, and transporting everything from point A to point B. Is this a process that you can...

toy brick house child
How To Make Moving Less Stressful For Children

Moving is a stressful affair for anyone, but adding young children to the mix makes it even more difficult! Although there will undoubtedly be tears and tantrums along the way, there are some actio...

woman purple lights background silhouette
Artificial Intelligence And The Risk To The Immigration Sector

​It's no longer a science fiction fantasy...Artificial intelligence (AI) was once a sci-fi fantasy of the future; now, it is a functioning and ever-increasing part of numerous industries, including...

young professional man working at laptop
When To Consider Using An Employer Of Record

​What exactly is an Employer Of Record?Many of us have never even heard of an EOR, let alone used one's services. So, what exactly is an EOR, and why should you use one?Employer of Record (EOR) ref...